FILTH AND WISDOM
Critics give Madonna a gentle mauling for directing debut
BERLIN (AFP) - Critics slipped their knives into Madonna's directorial film debut "Filth and Wisdom" on Thursday, but stopped short of a fatal twist and instead offered the pop icon a pat on the back for effort.
"Not much filth and precious little wisdom," was industry magazine Screen International's verdict on the film which premiered at the Berlin Film Festival on Wednesday.

"A good humoured, averagely amateurish vanity project," said the reviewer, who criticised Madonna's "creakily written" screenplay for claiming to satirise racial and social stereotypes while "lazily perpetuating" them.

In the end, however, he joined numerous others in confessing to an unexpected level of enjoyment.

"While chaotic and more than a bit silly, the film in the end conjures up a surprising amount of goodwill," it said.

"Filth and Wisdom," billed as a London-based comedy, revolves around a Ukrainian immigrant who finances his dreams of rock glory by moonlighting as a cross-dressing dominatrix, and his two female flatmates.

Madonna said she aimed to capture the uncompromising drive of young, talented people who believe they can make it in show business against the odds.

The film stars Eugene Hutz, the Ukrainian frontman for a real-life Gypsy punk rock band, Gogol Bordello, as well as British cult actor Richard E. Grant.

Hollwood Reporter found the film "ragged, uneven and potholed with some dire dialogue," but acknowledged that its "cockeyed optimism and likeable leads conspire to bring a smile by the time its done".

Reviews in the German press were more scathing, but also agreed that "Filth and Wisdom" had managed to save itself from joining turkeys like "Shanghai Surprise" and "Swept Away" in Madonna's acting Hall of Shame.

"Madonna has made a movie and it is utter trash -- pseudo psychology, cheap make-up, bad lighting and a hell of a lot of scenes shot without rehearsal," said the daily Der Tagesspiegel.

"But," the reviewer continued, "this crude business is all over as fast as a punk song and in that time you can have just as much fun. Not a good film, but a good surprise."

The Frankfurter Rundschau called it a "modestly produced comedy about survival" and argued that the film's dance and sex scenes were all references to Madonna's career as one of the most physical pop stars since Elvis.

"If you take her body out of her directing, then the film is nothing more than a picturesque little walk in the park. Just in the same way that her last tour was nothing more than a folkloric stab at subculture," the newspaper said.

The Sueddeutsche Zeitung said the film was "youthfully carefree" in a review that was unable to resist the soundbite swirling temptingly around the project ever since Madonna announced her intention to take the helm.

"This woman directs like a virgin," the newspaper said.
Source: AFP via Yahoo! News / Posted: Feb 14, 2008 - 3:20 AM
Filth And Wisdom
Great Britain, 2008
Lenght: 81 min
Format: 35 mm, 1:1:85
Written by Madonna and Dan Cadan
Cinematography by Tim Maurice-Jones
Camera operator: Peter Wignall
Edited by Simon Hayes
Choreographies: Stephanie Roos, Tiffany Olson
Production design: Gideon Ponte
Art Director Max Bellhouse
Costumes by B
Make up: Sinden Dean
First assistant director: Tony Fernandes
Casting: Dan Hubbard
Production director:. Sue Hiller
Unit Production manager: Gavin Milligan
Produced by Nicola Doring
Executive Producer: Madonna
Associate Producer: Angela Becker
Co-Production: HSI London
ColourCast:
A. K. Eugene Hutz
Holly Holly Weston
Juliette Vicky McClure
Professor Flynn Richard E. Grant
Harry Beechman Stephen Graham
Sardeep Inder Manocha
Sardeeps Frau Shobu Kapoor
Businessman Elliot Levey
Francine Francesca Kingdon
Chloe Clare Wilkie
Businessman's wife Hannah Walters
DJ Ade
Lorcan O’Neill Guy Henry
Nunzio Nunzio Palmara
Source: Berlinale.de by Deborah Cole Wed Feb 13, 10:10 AM ET
Filming of "Filth and Wisdom"
Source: AFP
Back to February 2008 Index
 
Filth And Wisdom
Great Britain, 2008
Lenght: 81 min
Format: 35 mm, 1:1:85
Premiere Date February 13, 2008 at 58th Berlin International Film Festival
Written by Madonna and Dan Cadan
Director
Madonna
Studio Exposure/HSI

Genre: Comedy / Drama / Music
Plot the story features a Russian immigrant, ballet school, lap dancing, cultural revolution, poetry, night club, punk rock band, book writer, dominatrix and gypsy.
Starring
Stephen Graham ... Harry Beechman
Richard E. Grant ... Professor Flynn
Eugene Hutz ... A.K.
Vicky McClure ... Juliette
Ade ... DJ
Olegar Fedoro ... A.K.'s Father
Gogol Bordello ... Themselves (also archive footage)
Elena Buda ... Ballet Student
Francesca Kingdon ... Francine
Clare Wilkie ... Chloe
Shobu Kapoor ... Sardeep's Wife
Tim Wallers ... Mr. Frisk
Elliot Levey ... Benjamin Goldfarb
Holly Weston ... Holly
Hannah Walters ... Mrs. Goldfarb
Inder Manocha ... Sardeep
George Keeler ... Frail Man
Produced by Nicola Doring
Associate Producer: Angela Becker
Cinematography:
Tim Maurice-Jones
Camera operator: Peter Wignall
Edited: Simon Hayes
Choreographies: Stephanie Roos, Tiffany Olson
Production design: Gideon Ponte
Art Director: Max Bellhouse
Costumes by B
Make up: Sinden Dean
First assistant director: Tony Fernandes
Casting: Dan Hubbard
Production director: Sue Hiller
Unit Production manager: Gavin Milligan
Additional Details
Runtime: UK:81 min (PAL Version)
Country: UK
Language: English / Russian
Color: Color
Filming Locations: London, England